Prior to Closing — Red Flags from the Seller’s Viewpoint
Buyers are expected to perform a thorough due diligence on both the business and the seller(s). However, many sellers don’t do an extensive due diligence on the buyer(s). Deals do not always close; many are aborted in the very early stages, and others tank somewhere along the way to what was hoped to be a successful closing. So, what happens that prevents a deal from closing, especially one that began with such positive signs? Obviously, in many cases, the buyer’s due diligence turns up some items that were not revealed by the seller, and others that can’t be resolved. Some of these items probably had early-sign red flags; other red flags occurred somewhere along the way, and unfortunately, the result was that there were pre-closing red flags.
The Early-Sign Red Flags
Sellers should seriously look at who the buyer is. This may be a corporate buyer who is just looking. On the other hand, some sellers may overlook a strong individual buyer for fear that he or she may be inexperienced in the acquisition process or might be too cautious. In both cases, the seller may want to ask questions such as the following: What companies have you already looked at? How much equity are you willing to commit? What experience do you have in what my firm does?
Some sellers have that sixth sense that allows them to size up a prospective buyer. No one wants to waste time with someone who really isn’t a buyer. The deeper a seller goes into the due diligence process with a potential buyer, the more red flags may appear. If there are too many, if the ones that get raised seem too difficult to resolve, or even if they might be resolved, if that sixth sense says “no” anyway, it is probably time to move on.
Red Flags Along the Way
Once the Offering Memorandum has been given to the potential buyer, the next stage of red flags may occur. For example, if your intermediary informs you that he or she has not heard from the prospect after receiving the memorandum, it could mean that the buyer prospect is not as interested as you might have thought. Also, if the next step involves a junior member of the prospective buyer’s management rather than the CEO or COO, the red flag should go up. If the prospect, corporate or individual, refuses to provide, or delays providing, information showing their financial capability to do the deal, the red flag should be raised. One recommendation is to set up a social event, a dinner or extended lunch between you and the buyer prospect. Visiting at a social event allows the buyer and seller to get to know each other, establish a cultural understanding and build a working relationship. If this meeting goes badly, the red flag should go up, at least half-way.
Red Flags Just Prior to Closing
The Letter of Intent has been drafted and signed. One area that may cause several red flags to go up is if the buyer’s attorney is inexperienced in the deal process, is overly aggressive, or just won’t bend. This is such an important issue that if changes aren’t made, the deal is probably in serious jeopardy of collapsing. The seller’s attorney may be able to gather some insight on this matter.
Both sides are taking some risks in any buy-sell process, but both sides should take their due diligence efforts seriously. If a deal has arrived at “a just prior to closing” status, it is certainly vital that both sides can resolve their red flag issues. It could be tragic if the deal has gone this far without serious red flags being raised.
The whole purpose of recognizing the red flags is to try to resolve them before the deal “craters”. A positive attitude by both sides is almost always the answer, and this attitude is best accomplished by the use of a professional intermediary who has been there, knows the red flags, and knows how to resolve them.
Do You Really Want to Sell Your Company?
Sellers have to ask this question and give it serious thought prior to making the decision to sell. In too many instances, sellers get to the proverbial altar and then back down the aisle. In most cases, this happens because the seller’s decision to sell has not been considered carefully enough.
There are the obvious event-driven reasons such as failing health, partnership, marital issues or because the business is going downhill. In cases such as these, business owners generally don’t have a lot of options. Selling the company is the easiest and most obvious one.
In too many other cases, the owner claims retirement, “burn-out,” or some other reason, none of which is necessarily a permanent state of things. Take the example of the owner of a company who is also the founder, and after a lot of hard work and probably years of financial hardship on his part, the company is now quite successful. It is, as they say, the owner’s “baby.” The first question that needs to be asked is: Do I really want to sell? The second question is: If so, why? And the third is: What am I going to do after the company is sold? These questions involve not only business decisions, but important emotional issues as well.
Attempts to formulate answers should not be made until the owner has discussed these questions with family and personal professional advisors. There are books on exit strategies and consulting firms that deal with these issues. A professional business intermediary is also someone that has experience in this area and can provide a good idea of current pricing issues and market conditions.
“Loose Lips Sink Ships”
The “loose lips” tagline was a common World War II phrase and was on posters everywhere. The problem continues on the business battlefront today. Leaks of confidential information coming from, apparently, some of the Directors of HP have been in the news everywhere. This is an ongoing story. If it can happen to HP, it can happen to anyone. Leaks of confidential data are a serious issue at any time, but are especially serious if they involve the sale of a company. Sellers are very concerned because of the impact a leak can have on their company and their employees.
Unfortunately, confidentiality is a Catch—22 issue. On one side, the seller wants to maintain it; on the other side, the seller wants to get the highest price possible, which can mean exposing the business to numerous potential buyers. The more potential buyers contacted, the better the chance of a good price being obtained—and the greater chance of a leak.
Owners may be overly concerned about leaks of confidential data, but since this is a concern, the issue must be dealt with. The shorter the time table between going to market and a sale the less chance there is for a leak. The selling process should not drag on! This is one reason why the price, terms and deal structure should be as fair as possible from the very beginning. The longer negotiations take, the greater the chance for word to leak out. If all of the red flags are dealt with early on, the more likely there can be a quick closing. That way, if there is a leak, the deal can be concluded before any damage can be done. The only other alternative is to deal with just two or three potential buyers. This, of course, lessens the chance of getting the seller a better deal.
Sellers should make sure that all documents involving a sale or potential sale are kept under lock and key, marked “Confidential,” and only transmitted to buyers in a secure manner. Confidential information should only be emailed or faxed when one is absolutely sure it can’t get into the wrong hands. Buyers and sellers have to be cautioned about the confidentiality issue. Too many times when there is breach of confidentiality, the leak comes from the seller. The seller tells his golfing partner, mentions it to a neighbor at a cocktail party, reveals it to a relative – indeed, it is usually a case of “loose lips sinking ships.”
If there was ever a reason to use a professional business intermediary, this is it. They can be the conduit between the buyer, seller and the outside advisors. Business intermediaries are experienced in preventing breaches of confidentiality, e.g. by requiring buyers to sign strict non-disclosure agreements. What’s even more important, they are pros, knowledgeable about dealing with one if it happens. This is just another reason to use the services of a business intermediary.
Small Companies That Can’t Afford to Sell
In many cases, the sale of a small company is “event” driven. That is, the reason for sale is health, divorce, partnership issues, even decline in business. A challenging reason is one in which the owners want to retire and live happily ever after. Here is the problem:
The owners have a very prosperous distribution business. They, unfortunately, are the embodiment of a value-enhanced business (see “12 Ways to Increase the Value of Your Company,” under Selling a Business). They each draw about $250,000 annually from the business, plus cars and other benefits. If the company sold for $2 million, after debt, taxes and closing expenses, the net proceeds would be, let’s say, $1 million. Sounds good until you realize that this sum represents only 2 years income for each (and that doesn’t include the cars, health insurance, etc.) – then what? Unfortunately, many owners of smaller companies claim they want to retire when the reality is that they just want to slow down, or eliminate the day-to-day responsibilities of running the business.
Those who want to retire, but don’t think they can afford to, may want to reconsider their decision. Perhaps they can’t afford not to sell. These owners may have already retired, at least mentally. The owner loses focus, decides not to invest the capital necessary to continue to grow the business and ultimately loses sales and profits or loses a key manager or salesperson, etc. This lack of enthusiasm will no doubt impact their business, lowering its value to a buyer when selling becomes inevitable. In the meantime, following their decision not to sell, they could lose a major customer, a major competitor might begin to eat away at sales — and profits — or a new competitor may move into the market. All circumstances that will reduce value!
Perhaps the owners will not have the “luxury” of changing their minds and deciding not to sell. If they are eventually forced to sell the firm because it is declining, they most likely won’t receive anywhere near the $2 million they might have earlier. The time to sell is when the business is at a high point. Using the services of a professional intermediary can bring the highest price possible. If you are thinking of selling but hesitating because “the time isn’t right,” take the step that can make all the difference. Seek expert advice, which is as close as your nearest business intermediary’s office.
The Key Ingredient to Selling Your Company
Business Appraisers, before beginning an assignment, like to know the purpose of the appraisal. Usually the assignment demands “bullet proof” documentation: comparables, EBITDA multiples, projections, discount rates, etc. Unfortunately, in situations where the purpose of the valuation is to establish a selling price, the business appraiser really doesn’t understand the business elements – or, since these business elements don’t figure into the numbers, they are largely ignored. However, they do have value; in some cases, significant value to a buyer.
Valuing these business elements requires that computers, adding machines and calculators be put aside. The business should be looked at from three key business elements: the Market, the Operations, and Post-Acquisition. These elements are certainly subjective, but also critically important to a prospective buyer. A buyer’s opinion of the business elements can drive the actual offering price significantly higher—or lower. In fact, the business elements such as Fundamentals and Value Drivers can impact price as much as the Financials.
Here are some important questions to consider:
Market:
Are there significant competitive threats?
Is there a large market potential?
Does the company have a reasonable market position?
Are there broad-based distribution channels?
Is there a wide customer base?
What’s the company’s competitive advantage?
Operations:
Are there significant alternative technologies?
Is sound management to remain?
Is there product/service diversity?
Are there multiple suppliers?
Many business owners feel that what prospective acquirers are looking for are quality and depth of management, market share, profitability, etc. Brian Tracy, in his book, The 100 Absolutely Unbreakable Laws of Business Success, states that the key ingredient is “a company-wide focus on marketing, sales and revenue generation. The most important energies of the most talented people in the company must be centered on the customer. The failures to focus single-mindedly on sales are the number one causes of business failures, which are triggered by a drop-off in sales.”
Tracy goes on to point out that company owners and/or presidents should observe industry trends, pay attention to what the competition is doing that works, and learn from them. Find out what is successful and what isn’t in your industry – trends are vital. It is important to understand that established and mature companies are generally just trying to protect their market share, while start-up companies are really attempting to gain or establish market share.
Tracy estimates that 80 percent of new businesses close down within the first two years, and 100 either fall off or join the top 500 companies in the U.S. because they are acquired, merged or broken-up, and even a few actually fold – Enron being a good example.
Tracy also mentions that problem solving, decision making and team (not individual) collaboration are key factors. However, as he points out, the best companies have the best people.
